The structuralist paradigm to discourse analysis defines discourse
as
"language above the sentence" and is based on the premise that language
is a mental phenomenon (thus you'll see shades of Chomsky). The
functionalist
paradigm focuses on language use and is based on the premise that
language
is a social phenomenon.
| Structuralist | Functionalist |
| "etic"--analysis based on form | "emic"--analysis based on meaning |
| Code-centered | Use-centered |
| Analyze code first | Analyze use first |
| Referential function | Social function |
| Elements/structures are arbitrary and universal | Elements/structures are ethnographically appropriate |
| All languages equivalent | Languages and varieties not necessarily equivalent |
| One code | Code diversity |
| Fundamental concepts taken for granted | Fundamental concepts problematic and to be investigated |
Adapted from Deborah Shiffrin, Approaches to Discourse, 1994.